The Cannoli Story

This is the story of the Christmas Cannoli. I teased it in my bio, but I’m finally ready to tell the tale. It’s a long story, so bear with me. It’s time to rid myself of the cannoli-guilt I’ve carried for so many years…

The Setting:

It’s the day of our big Christmas Eve dinner. The wife and I have hosted the extended family for years; brothers, sisters, in-laws, surviving elderly parents. Real Norman Rockwell stuff. Paintings of grapes on worn Italian tables adorn the dining room. The feast of salt-crusted prime rib and countless side dishes progresses. A high-back chair is situated on either end of the long table – one for each patriarch in attendance (my father on one end, and now me on the other) who would oversee the proceedings.

Everything was prepped, except for dessert.

The Story:

Now understand, I’m not a cake or pie kind of guy. Give me some pizzelles, Torrone, or biscotti and I’m a happy man. But why not make some cannoli? I’ve always loved those light crispy tubes filled with creamy goodness. Some with mascarpone and chocolate chips, some with dried fruit. And, of course, the pistachios. It sounded like a perfect end to the meal. And as if fate intended it, a co-worker had just gifted me a set of metal cannoli tubes upon which I could roll and fry the shells. Who am I to argue with fate; on this, the eve of the birth of Christ?

If I’m going to make cannoli, I’m going all the way. So, I bought a delicious red wine (Mondavi if I recall) to incorporate in the dough, imparting a lovely red/purple color with a distinctive Italian flair. While at the liquor store to buy the wine I decided to treat myself to a nice bottle of Knob Creek bourbon as well. I earned it, right?

And this is where the Knob Creek Walrus, as I’ve come to call him, began making baking suggestions.

I’m working the dough and the Walrus says, “It’s too loose.” So, I add some flour. Then the Walrus says, “It’s not sticking together right”, so I add some more wine. By the time the Walrus approved of the dough, there was about a third more purple Play-Doh-like goo on the block than I expected. But I have a lot of cannoli tubes, so we’ll just have more cannoli to enjoy!

I carefully roll out the dough to a uniform thickness. About ¼”, give or take. Then the Walrus and I cut it into strips to be rolled onto the metal tubes and dunked into a large cast iron Dutch oven at precisely 350 degrees.

I have this orange thermometer thingy with a long probe that will verify the temperature, so don’t start up with me about the oil and frying and such.

They sizzled, popped, and formed beautiful bubbles on their surface as they cooked in all their azure glory.

I slid them off the tubes and repeated the routine five more times. Then, I set the tubes aside to cool, envisioning them making their entrance as I filled them with a pastry bag on demand, right at the end of the meal. It would be my opus! A crescendo at the end of a glorious meal, filled with the diner’s choice of flavor, and delivered on a small, outdated bone china plate that only a room full of Boomers could truly appreciate!

…

Now, the meal is done. Bloody, potato encrusted plates, smeared serving platters, and giant serving forks were removed from the table. Steak knives, spoons and regular forks took their leave as well and were replaced with little forks that, for some inexplicable reason, have one grove in the middle that’s longer than the other grooves.

But I digress.

The tiny plates had been placed in front of the guests as the Walrus and I entered the room with our tray loaded with tubes and fillings.

The guests shouted out their orders: “Chocolate Chip for me!”. “I’ll take the one that’s flavored like an orange!”, and “I’ll just take cheese filling with no other stuff in it because I have a problem digesting anything too hard or too sweet and my chiropractor said this is why I can’t control my farts.”

I filled each shell with the loving dedication of one who assumes that the spirit of a creepy fart-obsessed chiropractor was watching.

Having served the guests, the Walrus and I took the empty tray back to the kitchen, then re-entered the dining room to humbly collect our accolades. But each cannoli on each little bone china plate was untouched. No one had eaten a bite, yet no one said a word. I set upon eating the cannoli I had made for myself.

Except, I couldn’t break the shell. I couldn’t cut it. I couldn’t smash it into pieces if I had Thor’s hammer. Somehow, the dough had formed into a form of space shuttle heat shield that was (almost, except for that one time) impervious to the stresses of atmospheric re-entry.

They were inedible.

Quietly I panicked and in a hushed voice asked the Walrus what I should do. He suggested that, since everyone had already acknowledged the freakish tensile strength of the shells, we should turn in into a fun game to distract from our shame. And so, we did.

I started by taking a shell and putting a cast iron skillet on it to see if it would break under the weight. I then added a 5 pound dumbbell. Then another skillet. Then another dumbbell. At this point, the shell was bearing about 25 pounds of weight and mocking me, the guests, and the Walrus. And all this was happening in Norman Rockwell’s dining room.

Finally, the Walrus issued me the ultimate challenge: “Put a cannoli on the floor, stand on it with one foot, and have it support your body weight for 5 seconds.”

Game on.

After accepting the Walrus’ challenge, I climbed atop the cannoli in my New Balance shoes, extended my arms out to the side, and counted to 5-Mississippi. The cannoli shell prevailed.

In the end, everyone just scooped out the filling out and ate it with their weird little forks. The tiny plates were cleared, everyone eventually grabbed their coats and the house, once again, fell silent. The shells were all thrown into the trash, ultimately becoming a landfill problem for the aliens that invaded our planet centuries later.

But that’s a story for another time.

The Epilogue:

People ask me if I learned any lessons from the Christmas Cannoli.

Truthfully, no.

The Walrus and I still share the Holidays together, though some of the attendees have since gone on to their eternal rewards. The wife and I have gone keto, so there hasn’t been much cannoli around these parts for quite some time. The New Balance shoes have been replaced with Skecher’s Slip-Ons, and I retired the cannoli tubes to the basement kitchen.

That’s right. I’m an Italian and keep an extra kitchen in my basement. I didn’t make the rules, I just abide them. Don’t make the me and the Walrus kick your ass, you Italiaphobic, non-basement kitchen heathens.

A-hem.

Merry Christmas to All and to All a Good Cannoli.

Leave a Reply